Google continues to eat itself, by feeding more and more of its products into the ever hungry maw of Google+ The latest is their start or home page, iGoogle. For those of you who are not sure what a home or start page is, the page that pops up when you start your browser is your home/start page. It's an often overlooked resource, because it can pull in RSS feeds, link to news feeds, keep you informed about your email and a whole lot else.
My personal favourite, and the one that I teach on courses is Netvibes. It's very stable, has been around for years, provides as many different tabbed pages as you need and also allows you to publish material for other people to see. It's widely used by libraries and universities. However, if you'd like to try some alternatives, here they are:
Allmyfaves. This is a kind of start page, except that you can't yet add anything yourself. It simply lists lots of categories and then lists 10 resources in each listing for you to click on. The interface is jammed with site icons and is overpowering, and not something that I'd like to use myself. You may be different however!
Bonzobox. This is an interactive web tool that allows people to build their own customized "BonzoBox" home page with links to their favorite websites. Click, drag and drop. Nothing especially interesting about this one, and it didn't really have a wow factor for me. As good as many of the others out there.
Favoor. Very basic, but it seems to do the job.
Internet Buttons. If you have a friend or relation who is not too up on using the net, or you wanted to create a really simple home or start page for someone, try this one. Very simple - choose the link, choose the buttons and choose a URL. Point friend/relation to 'their' page and it makes life easier for them.
Kadaza. You can only choose from an admittedly huge list of resources broken down into a wide variety of different options. You can move their position, but that's about it. Not a bad idea if you just want to be presented with a bunch of options, but very limited personalisation.
Nextaris. Your all-in-one toolkit for searching the Web, tracking news, capturing Web content, sharing files, publishing Web blogs, and private messaging.
Pobb. This is an online Tool to create your own unique eHome, with links to your favourite places on the Net and lots more.
Protopage. It's a home/start page. Very basic, but fine if you want to try out the concept.
Schmedley. Lots of options, plenty of widgets that you can move around, you can add new tabs and so on. It does look as though some advertising is forced on you though, which is a shame, and it's one of the reasons that I'll be sticking with Netvibes.
Sitehoover. This is a simple to use home page resource that works using thumbnails for sites that you input yourself. If you register (which you'll need to in order to keep the page you create) you can theme it, import bookmarks from Firefox, use RSS feeds and create public 'hoovers' as well.
Spaaze. This is a cross between a start page, Wallwisher and Glogster resource. Add content, move it around the screen, add in images and video, put in links and so on. They are going to go for a pricing model, which probably isn't that sensible, given the free resources that are overlapping into this territory.
Start. This one looks ok, but a bit clunky to start with. However, you can actually edit the HTML to make it look nicer - if you're ok doing that of course! Supports RSS feeds.
Symbaloo. This is really nice as a start page. Looks a bit noddy, with large block icons, but you can add your own, drag in bookmarks, rearrange things, add tabs and so on. It's not as sophisticated as some resources like Netvibes, but if you want something quick, easy and uncomplicated this has to be in the running.
SymbalooEDU. This is an interesting twist on their existing start page offering, which I've blogged previously. They now have version optimized for teachers, allowing school branding, customised content, webinar training, with a maximum number of of users. It's also free of any advertising.
Tizmos. The thumbnails are quite large, and I can see how this could actually be a nice way of display a bunch of pages that you want to take people to; a nice training aid in effect.
Transferr. This is a customised home page that lets you quickly and easily access your favorite web sites, manage your favourites, and share single or whole groups of your favourites with others. Transferr creates icons of your favourite sites ready for easy access. You can add a favourite site to your hompage by simply typing in the address, or you can import favourites directly from your web browser. Transferr allows you to manage your favourites by colour and by keeping them in tabs.
uStart. This looks very good indeed actually. Same format as Netvibes. Good approach, wide variety of widgets, very neat. Can't see a way of sharing content, which lets it down a bit, but this looks like a good alternative.
Webnavigo is Polish, but it's easy to work out what it's talking about.
Webwag. Looks painfully like Netvibes. Lets you create you create your own content, tags and so on, and will populate a page automatically for you. Looks nice and simple, possibly more attractive than Netvibes itself in fact.
Wonderpage. It's a start page by any other name. However, as the description suggests, it's a very visual resource with a grid of pages.
Woolik. You can resize everything, add in your own backgrounds and move all the widgets around. I didn't see an option to add in your own sites however, just to choose from a pre-selected list.
YourPort. Bringing all your favorite sites together in one place. Why use Yourport as my homepage? Automatically sync to your own bookmarks. No login or sign-up needed. Share your favorite sites with friends. Its Free to us. Very basic, with large button icons.
Zeadoo. Quote from their site: "Zeadoo is your personal homepage for searching, bookmarking and sharing websites with friends. The site is designed for anyone who wants a simple, customizable page that they can access with one click from anywhere in the world."
Zenstart. These people say that they've got 'the best start page', but it doesn't allow you to add your own resources, there's no opportunity for RSS feeds, no widgets - just a series of pre-assigned lists of sites. All you can do is change the position of them within the 6 assigned categories. It's also very American biased. Until they can add more functionality, this is just a listing of sites - and not a very good one either!
I haven't listed Pageflakes, since it had its heyday a long time ago - and it fell into a sharp decline several years back. I personally wouldn't touch it with a bargepole. As for iGoogle itself - the message is perfectly clear - just don't trust Google. With anything really.
The problem with Netvibes is it only allows 4 widgets on a page and wastes tons of screen real-estate. It's a shame because apart from that it's a great alternative, but just doesn't show enough information in one go. Also, I found it very slow to refresh widgets on page reloads.
As for the others, not one of them comes even remotely close to competing with iGoogle for features and customisation. So yet again users are left screwed!
Posted by: James | July 04, 2012 at 01:17 PM
James - sorry but Netvibes allows loads of widgets on a page. My home tab has over 25 widgets at the moment. Are you sure you're not getting confused with the number of columns?
Posted by: Phil Bradley | July 04, 2012 at 01:21 PM
Thanks for the comment on uStart.org!
But there actually is a way to share content (little arrow next to every article)
uStart
Posted by: ustart | July 04, 2012 at 01:41 PM
Hi Phil,
Yes you're right, I was assuming (incorrectly) that each of the 4 "column" areas could only contain 1 widget. I've now managed to set up NetVibes to practically mirror my iGoogle page. The only thing missing is a Google Reader widget!
Posted by: James | July 04, 2012 at 02:10 PM
Thank you for compiling this list of alternatives to iGoogle. Most other sources say NetVibes and stop at that. I have faint hope Google will reconsider, but am heartened to know the landscape of free personal start pages is not barren.
Posted by: Holland | July 05, 2012 at 08:12 PM
The only problem I can see is that there is no way to integrate a Google Reader widget. I know you can import your feeds, but I don't want that. I don't like the way NetVibes works for RSS.
Posted by: Lufferov | July 06, 2012 at 11:08 AM
Thanks, Phil, for this comprehensive list of alternatives. I looked at uStart but decided it looked too Yahoo-like, so went with NetVibes and replicated my existing iGoogle screens reasonably well. Only shortfall I've seen so far is that the gmail Widget seems to display only the unread emails - at least I could not find any way to configure it to do otherwise. And of course I can always get to full gmail from the Widget.
Posted by: Chris L | July 07, 2012 at 07:42 PM
What Lufferov said. You need a widget for each feed, which doesn't work very well if you have dozens of them. I'm really astounded that it's this hard to find something to replace the simple things iGoogle does. That Reader widget... Irreplaceable, apparently.
Posted by: LaFlamme | July 08, 2012 at 07:41 AM
has anyone tried Yourport.com.
Posted by: dean | July 08, 2012 at 10:28 PM
Thanks for adding ALL MY FAVES... I'm the editor of AllMyFaves, and actually we're 100% CUSTOMIZABLE!
You found our original homepage, but if you try out http://allmyfaves.com/join, you'll find that you can add your own bookmarks, sync them across all devices, and customize them any way you like.
This is the post we just wrote explaining more about how AllMyFaves is a great iGoogle alternative: http://www.allmyfaves.com/blog/allmyfaves/igoogle-shutdown-allmyfaves-is-the-perfect-alternative-homepage/
Posted by: Danny Davies | July 09, 2012 at 06:45 PM
Hi Phil,
Would love to be added to the list of alternatives though we are just beginning our journey.
Before it shuts down, please give Skim.Me (http://skim.me) a try. I'm a founder and you can email me at wu at skim dot me with what you don't like about it. We make your daily online routine more productive and have been working on this for the past year.
Your routine sources are automatically setup, personalized and managed for you. Browse content from your sources in timed batches throughout the day and see how much you've accomplished, never how many unread you have. Releasing summer 2012!
Posted by: ClintonWu | July 21, 2012 at 05:09 AM
Hi Phil, I am the owner of http://yourport.com Thank you for mentioning the site on your comprehensive break down of each alternative. There are so many great alternatives to Google out there and it is great that you are giving them all the publicity they deserve. Great work and many thanks. I hope your article is shared.
you can find us on
website - http://yourport.com/
Twitter - https://twitter.com/YourPort
Facebook - http://www.facebook.com/pages/Yourport/131205203625130
Posted by: dean | July 31, 2012 at 11:56 AM
For all people who would like to see more about how to start with Symbaloo after having used iGoogle, we setup this special page: http://blog.symbaloo.com/igoogle-alternative/
Thanks for mentioning Symbaloo by the way!
Posted by: igoogle alternative | August 02, 2012 at 09:15 AM
I used myway.com before Igoogle, and am looking to see if I want to go back to this, I remember it was very clean and customizable.
A description of their service is at:
http://info.myway.com/index/id/ourmission.html
Posted by: mml5125 | August 03, 2012 at 08:06 AM
Wonderful list, Phil! Thanks for sharing!!!
Posted by: John DiGilio | August 08, 2012 at 07:23 PM
I like uStart, it does most of the things you could do with iGoogle and it is pretty easy to use. Check it out.
Posted by: Damien Quick | August 12, 2012 at 01:22 PM
Hosting alternative for XML iGoogle gadgets: http://host.gadget-blog.ro/
Posted by: Daniel George | August 13, 2012 at 09:53 AM
Thank you Phil, great alternative Netvibes for iGoogle
Posted by: marc | September 10, 2012 at 05:52 PM
i also want to reproduce the Google Reader widget - i love the way this works on iGoogle and can't find an alternative - ie one small window through which i can easily access dozens of RSS feeds.
Please, anybody, let me know if you find an alternative! Thanks!
Posted by: Mike Conradi | September 11, 2012 at 05:43 PM
Also have a look at Yourls (http://www.yourls.com). It allows you to build a very simple startpage around your favorite links.
Posted by: arjen | September 13, 2012 at 11:30 AM