Stumpedia, which describes itself as "a social search engine that relies on human participation to index, organize, and review the world wide web" has now started to provide what it terms 'instant answers'. These are not the same kind of small potted answers that you get with a search engine like Ask however, oh no. These are questions that you can ask that are routed through to a human being. One of many I should point out - I don't think it's one poor soul chained to a keyboard.
However, which person or persons this may be, we have no real way of knowing. You can ask a question and Stumpedia then utilizes a resource called Muchobene to pass the query onto someone who may know the answer. "The Muchobene plug-in allows you to share your knowledge with other users by responding to their questions."
I asked a fairly straight forward question - 'when was the American Civil War' and after a few seconds up popped a chat window and someone (no idea who) gave me the answer 1861 - 1865. Well yes, but not great, though to be fair, after a few seconds they came back with a fuller response. Which was vaguely correct, depending on how pedantic you feel like being. You can see this in the screen shot.
Well yes. Except no. No citations were offered. I am left with no idea who the person is who answered my question. I have no idea if it was right or wrong. This is just plain insanity, and quite frankly I can't see this working at all. It's really nice that people are prepared to give up some of their time to help others but really - go and add something to Wikipedia if you want to do that. I couldn't use this information with cross checking it, it's really unusable in this format. Cha Cha tried it for a while and they've now dumped that in favour of mobile answers. It didn't work for them and with the best will in the world, I can't see it working for Stumpedia. Of course, the only exception I can quickly think of is where the person at the other end of the chat gives you a URL or other reference that you can check; my second query 'is there a crystal mineral that forms long, flat fragile shapes' was answered rather better, since I did get a URL I could use. However, I still remain to be convinced.
Recent Comments